Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Categories
- All Discussions27,119
- Orphaned Marques
- ↳ Hudson21,185
- ↳ Street Rods805
- ↳ Off Topic564
- ↳ American Motors149
- ↳ Kaiser - Frazer70
- ↳ Nash71
- ↳ Packard163
- ↳ Studebaker121
- Classic American Cars
- ↳ Ford Motor Company959
- ↳ Chrysler Corporation478
- ↳ GM Corporation1,394
- ↳ Post War Chevrolets75
- ↳ Pontiac Forum119
- General
- ↳ All makes1,961
- ↳ Poll Discussions24
- Swapmeets & Events
- ↳ Events130
- ↳ Swapmeets108
- Hot Rod Corner
- ↳ Ford Rods90
- ↳ Lead Sleds67
- Special Interest Groups
- ↳ The Flathead Forum139
- European marques
- ↳ MG Car Company2
- ↳ Mercedes-Benz2
In this Discussion
- 1951hornethardtop December 2012
- 54SuperWasp December 2012
- bobdriveshudson December 2012
- boothguy December 2012
- Browniepetersen December 2012
- DocHubler December 2012
- dover1 December 2012
- essexcoupe3131 December 2012
- Kdancy December 2012
- Kevin C. December 2012
- lostmind December 2012
- nick s December 2012
- onerare39 December 2012
- PAULARGETYPE December 2012
- RonS December 2012
- Tallent R December 2012
- TOM-WA- December 2012
Study on oil
-
Not that this is news to anyone, but I thought I would pass it on:
"Machinist's Workshop" recently published information on various penetrating
oils. The magazine reports they tested these products for "break out
"torque" on rusted nuts and bolts. A subjective test was made of popular
penetrating oils, with the unit of merit being the torque required to
remove the nut from a "scientifically rusted" bolt.
Average torque load to loosen nut:
No Oil used ........................516 foot pounds
WD-40 ..................... ........238 foot pounds
PB Blaster .........................214 foot pounds
Liquid Wrench ......................127 foot pounds
Kano Kroil .........................106 foot pounds
ATF/Acetone mix...................... 53 foot poundsBrownie -
ATF I assume is automatic transmition fluid? And I assume acetone is acetone. What is the ratio of the mix or can you buy this off the shelf? Bare with me I am out of the loop on a lot of this stuff.
-
-
I was told be an old millwright who had learned from an old mechanic that Used ATF was the best penetrant available. I assumed it aplied to fluids before all the stabilizers and aditives we have today. Perhaps acetone breaks down the additaves and provides the benefits of usage perhaps even moreso.
-
I have had a 50/50 mix trying to unstick the motor in my 52 Ambassador with 43k miles for about 10 weeks. It was well stored for only 41 years but no miracle yet. I'll let you know if it works.
-
Boothguy, did you fill the engine completely up or just put in the top of cylinders?
reason I ask is that I have found some engines will lock up in the rod pin area and that locks the piston in place. -
Brownie, The very best penetrating oil I have ever used is called " Freeway " it is made in England. Our shop in San Diego was Rolls Royce Aircraft Engines warranty site and it was the only approved brand we could use. It is by far the very best. The cost of Freeway at that time was around $95.00 a gallon and at that price I was looking for a less costly product. A old race buddy told me about the ATF and acetone mixture which I have been using at home ( but not on Rolls Royce aircraft engines, not approved ) for at least twenty years. The mixture I use is 50/50 and is the second best penetratent have ever used. The third best for me has been Kroil. Hope this helps Merry Christmas to you and yours. buzz
-
@Kdancy: Boothguy, did you fill the engine completely up or just put in the top of cylinders?
reason I ask is that I have found some engines will lock up in the rod pin area and that locks the piston in place.
This is a very good advice from you cause, I thought my engine was stuck, nothing moved. Had put oil in cylinders and nothing happened. When, I don't know why, I removed the water pump, I found everything was ok. The fact is: The impeler, inside the water pump, was glued with rust to the motor. I just sanded the rust and the motor started easily... Michel -
I found a 202 Jet engine condemed as "Stuck" was the same way. Pump impeller rusted back to motor front. Very good and tight V-belt and starter wouldnt budge it,
RogerRetired Tech. -
I just filled the area above the pistons through the spark plug holes, removed the belts, starter and rocker arm shaft, sprayed the valves with oil, tried to get it down the guides,Had to tap a couple of valves to get them to pop up. Using a crowbar on the flywheel to the point I'm worried about the teeth breaking off. Oil looks good as does the antifreeze that came out of the radiator. Hadn't thought about filling the whole engine with the mixture, how much would it take to fill it? Would it stay in long enough to reach the top? Not sure what my next move is. The engine is so clean I just can't believe there is anything major wrong with it.
-
I sprayed a bit of WD-40 in the spark plug holes. While I had the radiator off and the generator in for rebuild I put a wrench on the flywheel and it turned with no effort. The water pump is free as well. Plan to pull the pan this week to check under side of engine before I start it up.Brownie
-
THANKS FOR THE OIL INFO BROWNIE I'M A ''Kano Kroil'' MAN WHEN I RESTORED BABY ( 50 PACEMAKER CV) THE CAR HAD SAT OUT FOR 40 YEARS I SPRAYED EVERY BOLT AND NUT ON THE CAR WITH KROIL AND I DID NOT BRAKE ANY BOLYS OR HAD NONE STRIP I WAS REALLY CAREFULL WITH THE TOP PARTS AND SOAKED THEM FOR ABOUT A WEEK 2 TIMES A DAY WITH OUT BRAKING ANY THING IT MADE A BELEAVER OUT OF ME WHERE WOULD I BUY Acetone??
-
Ace Hardware sells it.
-
Some Freds and maybe other dollar stores. Good luck, Bob
-
Home depot sells it by the gallon in the paint dept.
-
For those of you who have spent a good deal of time in the machine shop world or painting cars you have been introduced to the world of carbon based chemical solvents. MEK, TCE, paint thinner or reducer you have most likely been introduced to acetone. Acetone is distilled and is great for desolving plastic or urithane materials in paint. Some years ago it was identified as an agent that could cause cancer and for all but small amounts now sold in paint stores it is all but gone. These carbon based cleaners were often found in machine shops and used for cleaning metals after the machining process. Acetone is one of the more pure forms of the carbon based cleaners and is great for desolving things like hard grease, axel grease that has been applied and allowed to dry on surfaces like chrome are easily removed with acetone. Of the three that were most common, (MEK, TCE and acetone) acetone is the only one still being manufactured and available to the public. It has a strong smell and prolonged exposure can cause you to be lite headed and disorented (very painful drunk effect.) In the aerospace industry we would put it in degreasers, bring it to a boil, and dip parts in it or the heated vapor (i.e. vapor degreaser). So, There you have it-more than you needed or wanted to know.Brownie
-
If you are looking only for a very small amount of acetone at home
grab the wife's nail polish remover as that is acetone based
Mike -
Brownie,
I'm a chemist and you are spreading some misinformation about chemicals. Acetone does not cause cancer and has never been found to do so. It's a very important industrial chemical and is used in many products that people use today. The US is the largest producer of this chemical. It's actually a very simple 3 carbon molecule, and is quite flammable -- its primary hazard. And essexcoupe3131 is right that it is used in nail polish remover.
One the other hand, TCE (Trichloroethylene, a chlorinated compound) is a carcinogenic compound. TCE is a feedstock chemical to make refrigerants like HFC 134a. Now that's kind of important for folks that live in the warmer southern climate! Used properly, it can make very important products for us. Hopefully the days of dumping chemicals like this into our environment are over, but it has been found that it requires constant vigilance to prevent those irresponsible actions by a few that leaves an expensive and damaging legacy to our environment and health.
MEK, or methyethylketone, is a class of compounds known as ketones, as is acetone. It is highly flammable also, but is used as a solvent for inks in dry erase markers, something you are probably familiar with, including the odor caused by that chemical. MEK, or butanone as it is known, upon further study, was removed from the list of hazardous air pollutants by the EPA and is regulated as a VOC, volatile organic compound.
All of these chemicals are still produced today and used for various purposes. A good general place to look up info about these chemicals is on Wikipedia. It is not the best source, nor is everything entirely accurate at all times, but it is a good place for the non-chemist to start.
As car guys, chemicals are very important in this hobby. From the chemistry caused by modern fuels with ethanol (and all the attendant problems with that one), to the paints and products we use to restore and preserve the cars with. Modern paints are excellent compared to what was used just 30 years ago, but they are very expensive. Part of that cost has been the process of getting the lead removed from pigments in the paint, and development of ever better plastic coatings (paint, clear coats) for our vehicles to make them look beautiful and remain durable for a long time. Also, the chemistry has been developed to reduce drastically solvents or reducers used in the painting process to keep emission of volatile organic chemicals low to prevent air pollution, primarily in the form of smog. Thankfully our Hudsons are made with good steel from the 30s-50s. Why people like to talk about the "tin" worm really makes no sense if you think about it; tin is relatively stable to oxidation, and therefore is used to form a water oxidation protective coating on cans of food, used for food preservation (hence the word tins or tin cans evolved). The other major use for it tin is in solder. Actually, there is another plastic coating on the inside of food cans that is now commonly used, and it may even have some health issues as scientists have looked into the issue and developed better means of analysis of materials that can leach from the plastic coating.
Someone else that knows a lot about these topics would be Dennis Gage from My Classic Car -- the guy with the extreme handlebar mustache. He's a PhD chemist, as I am. We both are graduates of the University of Idaho. He used to work at Proctor and Gamble before he went full time into his current car activities. i met him once in the 80s when he was out on a recruiting mission.
A final plea: tell your congressman and senators to support basic scientific research. They probably will say they do, but there is far too little fundamental research supported in this country, and it comes out of the discretionary budgets (which are facing drastic cuts). Consider more investment in science and technology for our country. The Return on Investment has always been very positive. We are living today on the achievements from the investments of decades ago; if we don't continue/increase those investments, we will almost certainly become a second rate player in the area of science and technology in the next 20-30 years. The security and general welfare/happiness of the country depends on continuing the high standards of the past in this area of endeavor. Also, far too many research dollars are squandered on administrative and management at all levels of this field, so we should demand more efficiencies out of that as well. Well, we should all try to get this message across to the government. -
Doc, far be it from me to question a PHD Chemist. My claim to fame is simply based on 44 years as a Design Engineer, Quality Engineer and Safety and Mission Assurance Manager working on the Space Shuttle Solid Rocket Boosters. My Masters Degree was in management so I am way behind you on technical issues. I am now retired 2010), but have written more than one MSDS defining the properties of the carbon based chemicals. The term most often used for these chemicals is "Suspected carcinogenic." And, that is the major controling factor that we used within our manufacturing facilities at ATK. We were over concertive with an attitude of better safe than sorry. And; just for the record (not that it is important), I have had more than one MEK headache. However with that said, I have no arguement with you on the subject. I am simply excited that you took the time to educate us on the properties, uses and effects of carbon based chemicals. And, in some ways you have made me feel much smarter. Thanks,Brownie
-
Brownie,
Cool place; been down to that area before, and knew a person working down there in the 90s (and maybe still). I'm sure you know a few things that the average scientist or engineer won't know with that kind of experience! I believe in working safe -- I certainly don't want to lose an eye, hand, or get cancer down the road just because of some laboratory work. But unfortunately an attitude of safety at any cost is really hurting this country from a productivity/competitive sense. We need and expect technical folks to be able to accomplish their work safely and competently, and efficiently, but by the time they have 20 watchers per person, well the finances just don't hold up. Basic science has served this country well and we should invest in it much more heavily (and yes, we need the engineering support to follow to accomplish the great things we can do to improve our standard of living).
I worked with a person here that was a rocket engineer and he worked on von Braun's team for the first moon shot and also on the space shuttle in the early days. Truly one of the best people I've ever worked with and I think he is originally form Utah; it was a sad day for me when he retired. I once was doing something we called the "mega" prep in graduate school, large scale synthesis of some chemicals, and we were using 20 gallons of ethyl ether at a time, which is extremely flammable and of course has a narcotic effect. When I would visit with folks outside of the lab, they could smell it on my breath, and I could also smell/taste if for many days after, and yes, had major headaches from that. I also worked on fluorine chemistry for a while and used some of the fuels you would probably be familiar with at your company such as NF3O and N2F2 (realize you worked with solid rocket boosters, but these materials had a history going back some ways). Just a scent of an organic and Boom! I know some folks that worked with Rocketdyne before they had the big explosion that killed 1 or 2 people about 10-12 years ago. I think in general that most people are too detached from all the products that they use and the associated risks/consequences. If you want a risk free world, it will have to wait until heaven; it seems that many in government think if we spend enough, we'll get it here and now. It is a complicated issue, for sure in which we just don't have the right balance currently in my view.
For me, I'm not sure if I'll be working at my current job much longer; not by my own choice. The government is politically impotent, and maybe not even solvent for much longer, They are laying off a lot of technical folks (and others to be sure); we started sliding down the cliff some time ago. It will be a sad day when we fall behind technically, but maybe that has to happen for the great majority of people in this country to understand what is at stake. I have trained some young researchers in my day, and believe we need to do more, but on the other hand, where are the jobs for these folks in the service economy of the US these days? I haven't been doing laboratory research for several years now, but have been working on training customs and border police at home and abroad on WMD counterproliferation with focus on radiation equipment for detection of illicit materials and also chemical weapons. Even though I'm not a great mechanic, I do enjoy Hudsons and old cars in general -- fun hobby with great folks! -
Brownie-I've had that MEK headache for three days. I stripped a chair and refinshed it for the wife.I think it makes the brain swell , sure feels like it.
Used alcahol to clean things up , it seems just as hard on the head as the MEK. -
Sorry for the spelling,can't get back in to change it.
-
Tim and Brownie,
Thanks for the insight into the chemicals and solvents that are present on our world. I'm glad also that we don't have solid rocket boosters in our automobiles.
John Forkner -
We wont need to worry about all this technical stuff much longer. Third world countries such as ours will have no further use for it . . .
RogerRetired Tech. -
Roger,
Sad, but true. I'm think I better start learning Mandarin..... -
THE SKY IS FALLING THE SKY IS FALLING.
WHY IS IT THAT AS WE GET OLDER MANY OF US THINK THAT THE USA IS GOING TO HELL, YET SOMEHOW SOMEWAY WE CONTINUE TO BE THE BEST PLACE IN THE WORLD TO LIVE. -
Sorry to make this a political rant, but.........
The President of the U.S. can make all this happen!
Executive Orders 10990 & 10998 allow the government to take over all modes of transportation, highways and seaports, including personal cars, trucks or vehicles of any kind and total control over all seaports, and waterways.
Executive Order 10995 allows government to seize and control of communication media
Executive Order 10997 allows government to take over all electrical power, gas, petroleum, fuels and minerals
Executive Order 10999 allows the government to take over all food resources and farms
Executive Order 11000 allows government to mobilize civilians into work brigades under government supervision
Executive Order 11001 allows government to overtake all health, education and welfare functions
Executive Order 11002 designates the postmaster general to operate a national registration of all persons
Executive Order 11003 allows the government to take over all airports and aircraft, including commercial aircraft
Executive Order 11004 allows the Housing and Finance authority to relocate communities, build new housing with public funds, designate areas to be abandoned, and establish new locations for populations
Executive order 11005 allows the government to take over railroads, inland waterways, and public storage facilities.
Executive order 11051 specifies the responsibility of the Office of Emergency Planning gives authorization to put all executive orders in effect in times of increased international tensions and economic financial crisis
Executive Order 11310 grants authority to the Department of Justice to enforce the plans set out in Executive Orders, to institute industrial support, to establish judicial and legislative liaison, to control all aliens, to operate penal and correctional institutions, and to advise and assist the President.
Executive order 11921 allows the federal emergency preparedness agency to establish control over the mechanisms of production and distribution of energy sources, wages, salaries, credit and the flow of money into US financial institutions in any undefined national emergency. It also provides that when a state of emergency is declared by the president, Congress cannot review the action for six months. The Federal Emergency Management Agency has broad powers in every aspect of the nation.
Will the POTUS ever use these? Who knows? I hope we never find out, but in the immortal words of Rahm Emanuel, "never let a good crisis go to waste".
Time to get off my soapbox.
Kevin C.
-
Very interesting and educational about the carbon based chemicals. Not my field of expertise and I learned something. Kevin, its scary about the power the government has accumulated over the years. Tom- Wa-, I do think the sky is falling. This country is still the greatest to live in but like all civilizations in the history of the world,the path we are taking is no different. The world today is total different than when I was young. Morally, ethically, econmically,etc. I have had the opportunity since retiring to do some charitable work with needy families. Years ago the attitude was different than today. People back then seemed to really appreciate the help we gave them to get them back on their feet. People today think they deserve help. Its their right to get this help. In other words its my right to get this help and I expect it. Instead of taking personal responsibility for their actions, they think they are victims or its someone elses fault that they are in this situation. I never thought I would see the day that people that were successful financially were deamonized like they are today. Thats enough of my soapbox. I had better get off before I fall off.
-
Yes today "Success" is a dirty word ,and someone with a pension they worked 30 years for has an "Entitlement" that should be taken away.
Sorry but I just dont understand . . .Retired Tech. -
NO! NO! thats not what Im trying to say at all. Have a Merry Christmas.
-
I doubt seriously that anyone other than the majority of todays elected politicians confuse "entitlements" with earned retirement. What kind of wackos would lump earned social security and pension funds in with generations of welfare familys and illegal aliens?
Only those who have an agenda...We should not talk of "entitlements" when what we really disdain are free goverment hand outs designed to support a whole class of people with the sole purpose of garnering more votes come election time. -
Wow, this topic covered a lot of ground. I would enjoy meeting you all at a national or regional meet too continue the discussion. I guess I think our political processes, with all its flaws is still the best in the world, but its a little like an old Hudson's wiring system. All the money and lobbyists are short-circuiting our representative democracy. We need some repair and overhaul.
-
I guess the part of this whole system that has me a bit miffed is that all american dream that permits us to work hard, save, invest right and then when we retire we live on easy street the rest of our lives. What a great dream where you can go from entry level to management by minding your business and working hard. Then government comes in, closes down your program. 90 percent of your company gets laid off, your over 65 so you go out and look for work and you are overqualified, over experienced and old so you cannot even find an entry level job other than at the front door of Walmart. You have built the good life so now it is time to sell off as many major assets as you can so you can live within your income. Now, I do not mind any of that. I am excited that I can make that happen--But, what does the government do when they find themselves overextended. Yep, they tax more, take away money that we have been forced to pay into programs that take care of others and then just tell us that there is nothing else they can do. And, then from their fancy vacation spots (man would I like a vacation) they tell us that we have not given enough and that there are others starving, homeless, uneducated, and uninvited guests within out country that the government wants to give housing, food and life elements to them all within givernment programs. Yea, sometimes I get a little miffed. But, I am just selfish.Brownie
-
I was refering to the recent political campign where the term "Entitlement" was applied to retirees on pention programs & social security the same as welfare recipiants.Retired Tech.




