Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

In this Discussion

49 Commodore Brougham - Say What?
  • 51hornetA51hornetA
    Posts: 2,338Platinum Member
    Anyone notice the odd things with this car for sale on eBay.



    http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/k0280474_W0QQitemZ260207415481QQcmdZViewItem?hash=item260207415481



    Its listed as a 49 Commodore but there was no Commodore Brougham in 48 or 49. The vin number listed starts with 484 which makes it a tag from a 48 Commodore Eight. Even though car is listed as a 49.



    Here are the odd items. The steering wheel is not from a Commodore the taillights are but the side trim should say Commodore.



    Seems to me this is a 49 Super Eight Brougham trying to pass itself off as a Commodore. This car is up to 11K already. Not a bad car but it isn't a Commodore.



    0d25_1.JPG



    e5f0_1.JPG



    dc91_1.JPG
    www.hudsonmotorcar.org
  • Hudson308Hudson308
    Posts: 1,405Platinum Member
    No chrome on rear window = Super, black face on gauges, clock & speedo = Super, dash woodgrain ends at the doors = Super, no rear dome lights or armrest = Super, rocker chrome = Super, trunk latch & small trunk emblem = Super. I'll bet the VIN plate is screwed or pop-riveted on. :eek:
    Workin Stiff
  • hdsn49hdsn49
    Posts: 391Platinum Member
    This car is definately not a Commadore. Hudson308 you picked up on the same details as I did. Now if its an original 8, then it happens to be a very rare car. Very few Super 8's were ever produced let alone the fact that it is a Brougham.



    Because I have a 49 Super Six Brougham, I always pay attention to any 49 Broughams I have ever come across in person or online in the past 30 years. This could be the only Super Eight Brougham out there.
  • Hudson308Hudson308
    Posts: 1,405Platinum Member
    As I've stated in a previous thread, I believe Super 8 2-doors or converts are very rare. The fact that this guy probably had to use a '48 Commodore 8 VIN plate to validate his '49 Commodore 8 title (or vice-versa) would tend to confirm that... he likely couldn't find a 2- OR 4-door Super 8 plate. The only way left to tell the real origin of this car might be the engine serial number, tranny casting date or the dates inked on the back of the speedo, clock and some radios. Of course, he could have swapped all those out, as well. I'll bet a case of GOOD beer that the engine serial number starts with "493".
    Workin Stiff
  • Clutch guy
    Posts: 811Platinum Member
    Don't forget about the serial # on the pass.side front frame;)??
  • Hudson308Hudson308
    Posts: 1,405Platinum Member
    Clutch guy wrote:
    Don't forget about the serial # on the pass.side front frame;)??



    Doug; Where exactly is that stamped?
    Workin Stiff
  • hudsontechhudsontech
    Posts: 4,048Platinum Member
    "Its listed as a 49 Commodore but there was no Commodore Brougham in 48 or 49. "



    There was a Brougham model in 1948 and 1949 - but only in the Super 6 line.



    Hudsonly,

    Alex Burr

    HudsonTech

    Memphis, TN

    www.freewebs.com/hudsontech
  • Billy K.TN.
    Posts: 396Platinum Member
    Hudson308 wrote:
    Doug; Where exactly is that stamped?



    On top of frame between the cowl and bottom of brace from frame to cowl.

    on pass side
  • Aaron D. IL
    Posts: 1,648Platinum Member
    Yeah we were talking about them in the "rare production cars thread" Maybe be an altered (493) Super 8 Brougham. If so the only one I've seen in pictures. If I was going to win it I'd put it back in correct Super 8 trim.
  • SuperDaveSuperDave
    Posts: 2,378Platinum Member
    I wrote to th seller who is selling for his Brother in law. First I explained that he had a brougham, or two door sedan, not a coupe.

    The interior door trim is Super,the rocker panel trim is Super series, the steering wheel is super and last but not least, they didn't make a two door sedan in the Commodore series. I told him that he had a 48-49 Super that had been updated with Commodore pieces and a vin number off a 48 Commodore eight by a previous owner.

    He said he had gotten the same information from others. I also told him it looked like a nice car. I love those eights.

    The next owner of my 49 Super Six four door is at least getting the original vin plate, but that's about all!
  • Clutch guy
    Posts: 811Platinum Member
    As Billy noted is a good description.Sometimes you need to polish or wire wheel this area to find it.
  • Hudson308Hudson308
    Posts: 1,405Platinum Member
    You know, it wouldn't take much to rebadge this car with the correct VIN as found on the frame with one of the repro plates available from KGAP. You could then retitle the car here in Minnesota with the correct info. Swapping the taillights and dash trim back would be a piece of cake. You'd end up with a car that's not only correct, but much more rare than a '49 Commodore 8. A little more research revealed they didn't make ANY 8-cylinder broughams in 1948, no matter what the trim level. '48 Super 8's were available as sedans and 6-passenger coupes only. They made approx. 5,000 Super 8's in 1948 (both body styles). In '49 you could get a Super 8 as a sedan, 6-passenger coupe or a brougham only. They made approx. 6,000 Super 8's that year (all three body styles). No Super 8 convertibles were available either year.
    Workin Stiff
  • Aaron D. IL
    Posts: 1,648Platinum Member
    They may have not offered a brougham in '48 but if the VIN plate was indeed switched for a commorodore one it may indeed be a '49 car for all we know. Guess the block (assuming that wasn't swapped out) would tell us for sure. Someone told me the only other real way to tell a '48-'49 apart is the positioning of the trim clips above the windows on the front doors. Anyone know this to be true ?
  • hdsn49hdsn49
    Posts: 391Platinum Member
    Yes it is true. On the 48 Hudsons the clip is up front near the vent window. On the 49's it was centered over the front door window.



    Another differance found only on the Super Series is that the dashboards were all dark woodgrained and not two toned in 1948.
  • 51hornetA51hornetA
    Posts: 2,338Platinum Member
    He has listed the true vin its 491 so this makes this a 49 Super Six Brougham with a 48 eight cylinder engine he has listed the engine serial number its 484. He found the original title and the car was registered as a 49 Super Six.



    Nice of him to post an update. I bet he got a lot of emails from guys on this board.
    www.hudsonmotorcar.org
  • Hudson308Hudson308
    Posts: 1,405Platinum Member
    Glad to see he added the correct serial number info, even though it wasn't enough to get his reserve price. I emailed to let him know he can get repro VIN plates if he wants to correct that.

    As a clarification, Hudson obviously DID offer the brougham body style in '48... just not as a Commodore and not with an 8 cylinder. In '49 you could get one with a 6 or 8 in Super trim only.

    Another thing I wanted to point out is that Hudson DID start putting the lighter (two-toned) dash trim in their Super line late in the '48 model run... I've got proof sitting in my driveway. ;)
    Workin Stiff
  • SuperDaveSuperDave
    Posts: 2,378Platinum Member
    I think there is one other difference in a 48-49, but not fun to check. The spindles were different along with some other related front end parts. At least thats what the parts book says. Maybe they used pre step down parts in early production? Bill Albright will know.



    The seller asked me if he should reduce his reserve. My advice was to edit the information on the item, keep the reserve as is becuase last minute bidding usually spurts up. If it doesn't sell, he could relist with the lower reserve or offer it to the highest bidder.. I think the last bid I saw was very good for what i've seen of the car..pictures..only.
  • hudsondad
    Posts: 491Platinum Member
    I thought the auction ended with a very healthy price for this car. Can't imagine what the reserve may be, but I would think it's more than fair for this one, especially the color combination that is not very appealing.
  • Hudson308Hudson308
    Posts: 1,405Platinum Member
    Yeah, I thought the final price was fair for what's there. I'd also heard that there were spindle differences with the '48, but didn't have anything to reference to when I had 'em apart. Another minor mechanical difference between the early- and late-48's is how the driveshaft carrier bearing is supported. Early '48's have a separate support member bolted in longitudinally, extending forward from the subframe structural member just in front of the differential. Later-'48's on up have an additional (integral) subframe crossmember extending laterally at the carrier bearing point. As hdsn49 pointed out, window clip location is probably the quickest & easiest way to tell the difference, though.
    Workin Stiff